Daily News Clips
Office of the Chancellor / Public Affairs
Tuesday, May 18, 2004
 

Los Angeles Times 5-18-04

Faculty Gives O.C. College Chief 3rd Thumbs Down
By Jeff Gottlieb

 

Faculty in the South Orange County Community College District overwhelmingly voted no confidence Monday in Chancellor Raghu Mathur.

Of the full-time professors at Irvine Valley and Saddleback colleges who cast ballots, 93.5% voted in favor of no confidence, and 6% were against the union-sponsored measure. One person abstained.

Out of 318 faculty eligible, 246 — 77% — voted, according to the district faculty association.

"It's very clear that the chancellor does not have the confidence of the faculty," said Lewis Long, head of the faculty association. "Now it's up to the trustees to demonstrate whether they support the faculty and the students they represent."

Mathur issued a statement late Monday attributing the outcome to friction between him and faculty members relating to contract negotiations underway. "They are unhappy that I take direction from the elected Board of Trustees and not them," the statement said in part. "I believe that my day-to-day decisions and policy recommendations to the board need to continue to be guided by what is best for the students, first and foremost."

Donald Wagner, president of the Board of Trustees, characterized the vote as largely political. "I'm not surprised that it passed," he said, "because the folks who were agitating for no confidence refused to give the chancellor a chance to address the issues they raised."

Faculty at Irvine Valley twice voted no confidence in Mathur, where he served as president from 1997 until his appointment as chancellor in 2002, putting him over Irvine Valley and Saddleback College in Mission Viejo.

Faculty members have been at odds with the former chemistry professor since shortly after the conservative-dominated board named him president, and Mathur replaced a system that relied on faculty to handle much of the college's administrative load.

Trustees appointed Mathur chancellor even though a hiring committee did not rank him among the top three candidates, according to Lee Haggerty, then union president, who sat on the panel.

Teachers say Mathur and the elected board have taken away many of their powers to govern college life — powers given them under state law — and added rules to control faculty. They say that Mathur is vindictive, power hungry and intolerant of criticism and that the board has little respect for their opinions as professionals.

Wagner has said that the board refuses to be a rubber stamp for the faculty and that Mathur is carrying out its directions.

Despite the faculty's continued disdain for Mathur, the majority of the seven-member Board of Trustees is expected to continue to support him, as it has in the past.

Since Mathur's move into administration, the district has paid hundreds of thousands of dollars after losing faculty and student lawsuits charging that the district violated free speech rights, often after people directed their comments at Mathur. About 70 administrators have resigned, retired or returned to teaching since Mathur was appointed president, according to a list compiled by faculty.

Relations between the district and faculty have been driven even lower as contract negotiations have reached an impasse and a mediator has tried to bring the two sides together. The contract expired in 2002.

The union is gearing up for the November election, when it will push to defeat board members Tom Fuentes and John Williams, Long said. Also up for reelection is William Jay, who gained his seat in a special election in April and whom the union endorsed.

Fuentes, former head of the Orange County Republican Party, is especially well-funded, having raised more than $100,000.