Daily News Clips
Office of the Chancellor / Public Affairs
Monday, March 29, 2004
 

San Francisco Chronicle 3-28-04

In-state students feel UC's pain
Budget woes have Californians crying foul over changes
Phillip Matier, Andrew Ross

 

Despite state budget cuts that mean saying "no'' to 3,200 UC- eligible California high school graduates this year, the University of California is keeping the door open for thousands of foreign and out-of-state students.

"I feel very let down,'' says Suzanne Sloane, the mother of an East Bay high school senior who was among those caught up in the budget crunch.

Since adopting its Master Plan in 1960, the University of California has prided itself on finding a place for all of the state's UC-eligible applicants.

But with budget cuts forcing UC to slash enrollment by 10 percent, officials say they can no longer live up to the commitment -- and bouncing foreign and out-of-state students to make way for California residents apparently isn't an option.

"One of the strengths of the University of California is the diversity of its student body, and that includes students from out of state as well as out of country,'' said Hanan Eisenman, spokesman for the UC president's office.

Of the roughly 55,000 freshmen admitted to UC's eight undergraduate campuses last fall, 4,900 were nonresidents -- or nearly 9 percent. And while UC officials couldn't provide us with numbers for the coming year, saying admission notices are still being mailed out, they acknowledge the percentage of foreign and out-of-state students offered slots probably won't vary much from past years.

"If you are going to be a world-class university, you have to draw students from all over. ... It's part of your undergraduate experience,'' Eisenman said.

"That's a lot of hooey,'' countered Sloane, who argues that California already has a diverse population with large numbers of foreign-born residents.

"If they honored their mandate for California students, they would still have a diverse population,'' Sloane said. "This is not the Midwest.''

But Eisenman insists California students are the focus of the system's enrollment effort -- and notes that in-staters made up more than 9 out of 10 members of this year's freshman class.

Besides, he said, there are other reasons for UC to open its doors to out- of-staters, including the fact that nonresidents pay more than full freight.

And that load is about to get substantially heavier, because Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is proposing a 20 percent hike in nonresident tuition next year. That would put the annual cost of attendance for out-of-state and foreign students at $24,672, compared with $6,028 in fees for in-staters.

In other words, Eisenman said, "Nonresidents pay more than the cost of their education.''

What's more, he said, California has been warned by other states that "if we stop taking their students, they will stop taking ours.''

All of which is cold comfort to folks such as Sloane and her husband, both of whom attended UC campuses, and to her father-in-law, who taught at UC Berkeley for nearly 30 years.

"We were all raised with the idea that California has a great public university system, and that if our children met their standards they would be able to avail themselves of this system,'' Sloane said.

"And that's not true.''